Total dross Surely we can do better than this an insult to intelligent film goers. Infantile, peurile and limited. We have lost a great tradition of knowledgable, informed film reviewing. Egocentric and inarticulate to boot Pukeaverse11:27pm Fri 13 Apr
Rating 1.1
I quite like her She made the programme different, better, younger and more interesting to watch.. the only way it could be improved would be to do as wossy done and have behind-the-scenes segments of films.. BillyBobJones4:38pm Sat 7 Apr
Improved a bit - "Brilliant" :-) I managed to watch a few episodes in iPlayer. Claudia refers to 'thick'. But she's best at reading the written announcements :-) The word she uses is "brilliant". Little else. The short films Top5's are good though. But the live thing is fake - the tweets arrive right after - so that is not live! RS12:07pm Thu 29 Mar
Claudia is misunderstood! I love Claudia..she is a cookie, enthusiastic,well informed one-off who has a style that challenges the usual run-of-the-mill presenter. AND SHE AIN'T NOTHING LIKE THAT DREADFUL DAVINA!!! Jax3811:04pm Mon 26 Mar
Emmm Errr Pause... I can't listen to her emmm errrr pause errr "insert witty statement" errr emmm. Really awful, does she know anything about film? EndHer12:43am Mon 26 Mar
Good idea.... but CW doesn't work. Totally get what FILM were trying to do with the 2x presenter combo, but sadly it really doesn't work. Danny Leigh is great, but Claudia is a very, very, very irritating TV presence, and I find it really hard to be interested in anything she says. Ben - London11:24pm Fri 23 Mar
Get Kermode I love films and review shows but she completely ruins this. Yes, get Kermode in ASAP. Puddinghead6:23pm Fri 23 Mar
Don't get it. Why is this annoying dippy Joey Ramone lookalike still presenting film 2012?
Somebody please get Kermode before they loose all the audience.
Chris T11:32pm Thu 22 Mar
Orange She's orange, annoying, loud and only gets on shows because of who her parents are. Bighead6:25pm Sun 18 Mar
Get her off Get her off and let Danny Leigh do it on his own, he knows what he's talking about, she knows nowt about films. Hen Broon6:20pm Sun 18 Mar
Hopeless Bite the bullet BBC and get Mark Kermode in to do this show. She's hopeless. Fatty Foulkes6:17pm Sun 18 Mar
She'e awful She's awful, annoying and completely superfluous to the show. It would be much, much better without her. Arny Sak6:10pm Sun 18 Mar
Awful A film reviewer that neither watches, understands or likes films - must have a famous Mother or something KBeee12:00am Thu 15 Mar
Pathetic Is Claudia Winkleman for real? Her dippy schoolgirl persona is pathetic, You can tell she has used it all her life to get her own way but it does not wash with viewers who have an IQ over 60.
The BBC is now an absolute joke, Public Service Broadcaster my a... truth seeker9:56pm Tue 13 Mar
yeah great show, very entertaining loving the winkle Robert2:08am Mon 12 Mar
Another one bites the dust Just like 'Room 101', another great show has been ruined. Barry Norman must be weeping! Winkle 'er out!2:27pm Wed 7 Mar
Poor scheduling There are still people watching at 1:20 in the morning. Put it on at 4:30am when no one will watch the excruciatingly bad Winklewoman ruin yet another show Barry N.1:00pm Sun 26 Feb
Waste Film reviews by someone who neither likes films nor understands them.
Why isn't she reviewing chocolate? KBeee10:28pm Wed 15 Feb
Yak Horrible smug know-nothing. Wish Kermode would do it but he's too interesting. Nitz7:37pm Sat 11 Feb
We dont care about you! As others have commented before, this is unwatchable becuase of the truly awful presenter. She seems to think we care more about her than the films... Please bbc get rid come on!!1:19am Sun 5 Feb
Talent not required... ...when there is nepotism.
Daughter of Eve Pollard; step father is Sir Nicholas Lloyd.
Nuff said. Bros & Sis12:05pm Wed 1 Feb
It could be worse... ...her near-double - Shouty Davina - could be the host, perish the thought. Tina10:28am Wed 1 Feb
Winkleman - the unguided missile This woman is absolutely hopeless at presenting, at reviewing but most of all at listening to what her guests have to say. A space cadet. Radicalman9:17pm Fri 20 Jan
Re-commissioned? By whom? She must have er, friends, in high places. Loud-mouthed egotistical and unpleasant, almost makes you nostalgic for Wossy. Alright, I did say almost. At least he used to talk about the movies and not just about himself, in so called interviews with so called stars. Remind me to watch something else each week. Any old repeat will do. Retching-as-I-type6:41pm Wed 18 Jan
seriously ? another series with this idiot' it's who you know.6:44pm Wed 11 Jan
film unwatchable still this woman presenting? why! ex viewer4:26pm Wed 11 Jan
Submit Comment
Your NickName (will be displayed on TVGuide)
Read all TVGuide users comments on Film 2012 with Claudia Winkleman. Scroll to the bottom to submit your own comment.
